| Disappointment of the Year |
Sid Meier's Starships |
One Button Travel |
| Word/Puzzle Game of the Year |
You Must Build a Boat |
Auro: A Monster Bumping Adventure |
| Action Game of the Year |
Downwell |
Don't Starve |
| RPG of the Year |
Legend of Grimrock |
Galactic Keep |
| Adventure/Interactive Fiction Game of the Year |
Sorcery! Part 3 |
Ryan North's To Be or Not To Be |
| Wargame of the Year |
Pike and Shot |
Vietnam '65 |
| Multiplayer Game of the Year |
Subterfuge |
Sentinels of the Multiverse |
| Board/Card Game of the Year |
Card Crawl |
XenoShyft |
| Strategy Game of the Year |
Templar Battleforce |
Door Kickers |
| Creator of the Year |
Tin Man Games |
Slitherine |
| Readers' Choice Game of the Year |
Card Crawl |
Deathwatch: Tyranid Invasion |
| Editors' Choice Game of the Year |
Card Crawl |
Her Story |
